backstage.bbc.co.uk

Use Our Stuff To Build Your Stuff

Ideas

BBC News to Accept Trackback Pings

I thought this up a while back, but it's worth repeating in this arena.

Basically, bloggers tend to reference BBC News all the time. It would be good to be able to track all these references, and then be able to see what bloggers are saying about any one BBC news article.

My original proposal was to create trackback URIs for each BBC news article, with embedded RDF to enable auto-discovery and URIs that can be predicted from the URL of the article. I still think that this would be one of the best ways to implement it, but it might require some kind of moderation and, of course, wouldn't work for the articles already published.

So, some alternatives might be to simply track incoming referrals, and somehow weed out the blogs from the spam/unrelevant, or to use one of the newer technologies like pingback, etc.

You might think that sites like blogdex, technorati, etc already monitor what blogs are linking to, but they're not 100% accurate or complete, and don't always link to the permalink of the blog.

  • 12 May 2005 02:08 PM

Comments  Post a comment

I for one would make use of this- I've lost count of the number of times that I've referenced BBC articles in my blog- even though it is less than 6 months old. Trackbacks would need to be moderated of course, but there are lots of tools that do this (and for example the BBC could force all trackbacks to pass an automated test AND then hand successful ones to a human moderator- to cut down the number of spam trackbacks a human has to deal with)

  • 2.
  • On 12 May 2005 05:58 PM,
  • Vero Peps said:

This is a feature I would use as well without a doubt, but again, the spam concerns arise.

By adding an invisible field, the automatic spammers attempt to fill it, and those could immediately be discarded. Of course, as David said, there would still be a need for some human moderation.

Either way, great idea!

  • 3.
  • On 12 May 2005 07:29 PM,
  • Will said:

Seconded. Or do I mean, "thirded?" Great idea, and surely not too far off from "happening"........

  • 4.
  • On 28 May 2005 12:12 AM,
  • Thomas Rynne said:

This has been done, but not by the BBC yet:
http://wikiproxy.whitelabel.org/

It's desribed here: http://www.whitelabel.org/2004/10/04/dont-get-me-wrong-i-really-like-bbc-news-online

Very informative site. Good job. No proof of ideas: http://matrixsynth.com/blog/index.php/2005/09/06/exclusively_analogue_sequencer_on_the_ba_1 , through others who went there

Post a comment




Remember Me?




style: lo-fi | hi-fi